Planeswalker removal edh. Below are our 10 best red removal spells in EDH.

Planeswalker removal edh For discussing Magic: the Gathering EDH/Commander! Also instant speed Planeswalker removal doesn't work, unfortunately - you need to counter him or his ability can immediately be activated once he hits the battlefield, even if you have something like [[Anguished Unmaking]] in hand. Commander (EDH) forum Posted on Nov. I usually don't expect to be able to activate a planeswalker twice in an edh game Garruk, Primal Hunter should almost always be used for his -3. I’m including sacrifice, destroy, exile, and -X/-X effects and how they can alter an opponent’s strategies. It may be packaged into a sorcery, but it's a versatile one. [[Oko, Thief of Crowns]] is tied for the best planeswalker ever printed. One of the worst things in any game of Magic is playing a planeswalker and having it eat a removal effect from an opponent. 1, 2017, 3:43 a. Targeted planeswalker removal is something we've never gotten at common before. This deck focuses on the removal of my opponents creatures as well as casting large creatures. 32 - 6 Rares. Edit. Vs cEDH I think you need to use cheap, less flexible removal like stp, pte, nature's claim, pongify, etc and hope the types line up, since you can't always afford the flexibility tax. 18 - 0 Uncommons. Protect Planeswalkers: Comeuppance & Oath of Kaya. If you have 3+, folks have to choose Unfortunately in casual edh, many cards are win more, and this is without considering the synergy that it might have with your deck. People say it would kill EDH as a format, and others say it will do nothing but give more options to an endless Planeswalkers are not as good in commander in general. I fear the Threaten/Sac removal outlet in general has gone way down in utility since PrimeTime's banning. I’m currently building a [[Saheeli, the Gifted]] artifact deck that I’m really excited about. I also run Interesting. [[Garruk Wildspeaker]] ) I find planeswalker decks to be a fun idea, but inevitably end up being tiring for everyone. Esika, God of the Tree. The question of planeswalkers as commanders has been brought up in Magic discourse an infinite number of times. The best liliana for edh in my experience is [[Liliana of the Dark Realms]]. Deckcycle Feature Queue This deck is Commander / EDH legal. At 5 mana this would be great. Working with the League's Sphere of Influence rules (which currently say that you can only see players on your own plane), coupled with the current movement rules (which currently say that you may planeswalk to another plane after your draw step - but at the cost of skipping either your main phases or your combat step), I find people manipulating counters a lot (or simply aquiring all sorts of them) when I play against them in the commander format. 49 Tamiyo, the moon sage 2 Dovin baan . Thank you. Tezzeret, Master of the Bridge. e. 1 piece of Planeswalker removal. I'm not THAT much of For discussing Magic: the Gathering EDH/Commander! Planeswalkers aren't typically a huge problem in commander, imo. Here's mine. I understand it’s monoblack, but 3 mana is when spot removal needs to start having versatility to hit multiple permanent types, and given how weak planeswalkers generally That's how direct damage from spells works - so with something like [[Lightning Bolt]] you announce the target as the player and then redirect damage to the Planeswalker on resolution (I think) but with creature attacks, you attack the Planeswalkers directly. Planeswalkers have somewhat lost their relevance and strength Extremely new to mono black. Here are 12 planeswalkers a similar dollar value that are significantly better: Archangel elspeth 2 The eternal wanderer . Contempt currently sees play in 2,741 decks, which is decent, but I think Eat to Extinction can eventually overtake it. 30. 73 Narset, transcendant 4. Teferi, Temporal Archmage where he belongs: in the middle of a pile of planeswalkers, artifacts and mass removal. The playgroup sees all Planeswalkers are rattlesnakes for some reason, so I often drop it to eat up a removal so I can play the card I actually want to play. Now we will get a non-legendary copy of the planeswalker. Have some direct damage you can direct at planeswalker. Card Odds v1 Draw hand. tyrion66669. Budget. Honestly I don't even see why they aren't allowed because frankly at this point there are far more broken things that exist within EDH that there is no real reason for planeswalkers to be banned as commanders. DECKS. 21 - 0 Uncommons. View User Profile View Posts Send Message Experienced Mage; Location For discussing Magic: the Gathering EDH/Commander! Also instant speed Planeswalker removal doesn't work, unfortunately - you need to counter him or his ability can immediately be activated once he hits the battlefield, even if you EDH Planeswalkers, best to worst order imo: Tezzeret the Seeker; Karn Liberated; Elspeth, Sun's Champion; Venser, the Sojourner; Vraska the Unseen; Unless someone has tokens, most people don't want to swing into deathtouch, and if they do, then she's serving as removal so her + IS doing something. Problems: A commander deck should contain exactly 100 cards, including the . Edit: Shit, I forgot Lavinia of Any Planeswalker: Ok. With this version of Kaya, your chances of that happening significantly Hello All, I thought it’d be kind of nice to have a list of commonly used or useable removal spells for EDH. Collecting. There is a very big difference between Thassa's Oracle and the other two. Ult a walker is the ultimate goal but you can also just create very grindy board states. The basic goal of this deck is to get to six mana as fast as possible, cast Teferi and watch the magic happen. Darksteel Mutation is a popular card among EDH players that can be devastating if it successfully If it’s specifically planeswalkers that are giving you issues black has some really cheap removal from war of the spark but usually it’s either target planeswalker or target creature or planeswalker so not going to hit artifacts or enchantments if you are running into those. All the walkers work with the artifact theme to defend themselves and make tokens that can either attack, chump, or be fodder for Breya's creature-nuking In the board wipe department this is a different story, red has a terrific selection of sweepers. Sisay Toolbox is (still) competitive, albeit hampered by the quality of G/W walkers. Reply reply When it comes to spot removal, EDH players have many options to choose from, but some cards stand out for their efficiency, versatility, and impact on the game. . Upgrade your removal spells in EDH! We cover the best single target removal spells and board wipes in each color. €16. 52 - 0 Rares. However, you need to guard them from creatures, as foes Deadly Rollick. POPULARITY* 100%. r/EDH. A list of the most played MTG Commander Gruul Removal cards sorted by their popularity including their play trend. Look for walkers with removal and just use that removal every turn to make life miserable for the opponents pieces while protecting your own. I think it's also generally the case that people prioritize lower-mana cards over higher ones, when push comes to shove. If you have one walker on the field, it'l get killed. 2x planeswalker abilities: Oath of Teferi & The Chain Veil. Jan 27, 2023. 3 counterspells Usual: 3 wraths 5 instant-speed spot removal 3 Artifact or enchantment answers 1 piece of Planeswalker removal, and 2-3 ways of dealing with counters generically I'm pretty sure there aren't even 20 blue removal spells that are playable in EDH. The amount of Planeswalker Removal tends to be limited. For example [[dack fayden]] has a minus ability he can use the turn you cast him that is the spell [[steal artifact]] except Dack is 1 mana cheaper and can plus into [[faithless looting]] after stealing an artifact which makes him strictly better than [[steal artifact]]. In my [[Kethis the hidden hand deck]] being able to recur planeswalkers is especially potent. [[Dovin Baan]] good ult, rest is meh. However, most decks have at least one way to kill them, just because when a planeswalker works in commander, IT WORKS IN COMMANDER. Titan Forge: GET REKT!! A few months back, Wizards made Brawl free-to-play. Also Doubling season is a thing, with a always castable planeswalker you can cheat ults like crazy. Need some mana, I can get a rock. Cards: 100: Avg. Dreadbore, Vindicate, – Tokens are always nice, but the pump is somewhat small for EDH. [[Manabarbs]], [[Pyrohemia]], [[Ghirapur Aether Grid]], [[Impact Tremors]], and that sort of thing. Even broken planeswalkers in other formats tend to be bad in EDH. So if you have lets say [[Tamiyo, Field Researcher]] you have a real problem. 93 Tezzeret, artifice master Try to build up a bit of a board presence and then use creatures and targeted removal to protect the important planeswalkers. The newest one from MH2 was [[Liquimetal Torque]]. This deck does not appear to be legal in EDH / Commander. Two is kind of annoying, but doable. always have them be instants, sorcery speed targeted removal is generally too slow nowadays; 2. Updates Add. The downside is that an opponent has to draw a That's right, we're talking Planeswalkers this week. I often start building decks and as I’m go MTG Salvation Resident Planeswalker; Join Date: 4/26/2011 Posts: 3,489 I love planeswalkers, but I don't often like planeswalker decks. Deckcycle Feature Queue This deck is Commander / EDH It's ok I think it's a little slow since it's a top deck tutor and most budget to hand tutors are better. I basically built a grixis control deck where all my wincons are big dumb planeswalkers and it's a blast to play. She's often ignored so ults occasionally while smoothing out your land drops and the removal is nice. In this case, white removal refers to mono-white cards that fulfill this job. Planeswalker is a permanent card type in Magic, sparky bois, board wipes and pillow fort effects are great ways to fend off attackers. Theres already other suggestions for removal in the comments. Thassa's Oracle doesn't care if the creature dies. You can kill Jace with planeswalker removal before they win. If you have 3+, folks have to choose Single-target damage-based removal is therefore quite rare in EDH, as the format frequently contains much larger creatures than other formats, and the high starting life totals diminish the impact of a burn spell's flexibility. Top Planeswalkers (Past 2 Years) Group by. My current attempt is Slivers (Sliver Hivelord at the helm, Spot removal on planeswalkers is probably as common as attacking them. 36 Dack fayden 4. However, different players like different types of removal. Destroying any creature or planeswalker at the cost of a single black mana One problem Planeswalker has to stand up to 3 opponents looking to remove it. Teferi, Time Raveler. I'll try to explain: If your PWs take over the game you'll win. One problem Planeswalker has to stand up to 3 opponents looking to remove it. Obviously with a creature commander you can use stuff like Lightning Greaves and Swiftfoot Boots but those don’t work for However, in a Superfriends deck, Nahiri is an all-star, because she's removal that also synergizes with all the Proliferate and other planeswalker-centric cards like Oath of Teferi Oath of Teferi. Admin Regen Charts Download / Export / Embed Code. Reply reply People say it would kill EDH as a format, and others say it will do nothing but give more options to a perpetually endless pool of commanders. Honestly, though, I think some of the best anti-planeswalker tech is in red because of your ability to redirect player damage to planeswalkers. 4171 decks (0. The only downside is a rather limited removal mode with the -2. If I want a sword, I can get a sword. 20: The golden rule to Planeswalkers in EDH is this. I run [[Tezzeret the Seeker]] in a mono blue voltron deck. Red is also decent for artifacts Go to EDH r/EDH • by Good planeswalker removal for White Weenie? We'll be playing 4-player free-for all this weekend. Rarity (main - side) 26 - 0 Mythic Rares. You can be playing a discard deck (rielle), graveyard deck (which this fuels a lot for), proliferate deck (which this can go potentially (semi-) infinite with) etc etc. I really only run planeswalkers if they can do something good one time. 2 pieces of targeted land destruction. #23. These days you can find him at the draft table, brewing his 20th EDH deck or When I had my superfriends deck I realized that protecting my walkers against 3 opponents is way harder than just dropping them down and finding a way to ult. 4 - 2 Also unless you're playing competitive edh or they have lab maniac, killing someone's deck on turn 7 or 8 absolutely wins you the game. I usually run either Basri or the twins. Is it possible to build an EDH deck only with Art Series cards? Deck Filters. To be effective, they need to appear en masse. Had a look at your list. Comments. Planeswalkers in EDH. 19 - 5 Uncommons. e) I've put in quite a few pieces like [[Doubling Season]] and proliferate effects so that you can often ultimate a planeswalker the same turn you play it, meaning that it doesn't always have to survive until your next turn. 64 / $16. With all these choices of black removal and few cards that feel like 100% winners, it is Yeah, most of the time hitting planeswalkers is irrelevant. Three is getting rough. COPIES/DECK. Any $ $$$ Tags. I do hope they at least balance this by granting us more planeswalker removal or general answers; otherwise things will get silly really fast. The necessity of casting it for its escape cost if you want it to remain on the battlefield can make it a hazard in EDH if you somewhat depend on There was a time when Dreadbore was possibly one of the best spot removal We were just exiting the Jace, the Mind Sculptor era. In 63616 decks 6% of 1126152 decks. He has the two best colors for removal, is immune to most removal himself, and gives you benefits for removing your opponents' creatures. This deck is Commander / EDH legal. But its 3 abilities as ramp, card-filtering, and win-con all seem relevant. Planeswalkers have proven to be one of Magic's most popular card types, gradually amassing loyalty to eventually unleash devastating ultimates. Rarity (main - side) 18 - 0 Mythic Rares. Cards: 100: Planeswalkers are scary, and folks will be finding any way they can to remove them, no matter how innocuous their ults are, or even if they don't have ults. Related Posts. The most common commander removal spells won't work on planeswalkers. My current deck is struggling for planeswalker removal so should I run Detention Sphere? No, you should get better at stopping Planeswalkers from resolving in the first place and/or dealing with them with what your deck already has (or should have, i. Note: Now this is only my thoughts after seeing you put Vivien and Teferi as overrated, which I very much disagree with. The golden rule to Planeswalkers in EDH is this. They get +1/+1 counters, they get planeswalker talkers, they start combos with them, and they generally use them in all sorts of ways that give me problems. When you ult the same turn you drop them, your opponents never get to play their typical "response". This deck has that exact problem because unless your opponents are being very proactive with removing walkers, you end up with 10-15 minute turns of you just activating abilities in the correct order and shutting down opponents attacks because it has walkers designed specifically for Nicol Bolas EDH deck for a Planeswalker EDH league. Most Planeswalkers should be thought of similarly - Play them, get a major benefit, then not care about their removal. (): #13 Nov 30, 2014. I believe the truth is somewhere in the middle. Multicolored spells that splash black mana are also powerful and should be highly considered, but I focused this ranking on the mono While these are certainly ways to remove a planeswalker, I don't think they are particularly good options. So most us agree that if you were able to have a planeswalker as a commander (except the ones from the precons) would be severely over powered in comparison to creatures because they are way harder to remove, but what if instead of allowing all planeswalkers as commander only the ones from the Planeswalker decks could be played as commanders, since they are slightly To each their own, I think the current planeswalker package is better or similar in strength. If you only get a turn 1 activation did you get your mana's worth, or at least really close to it? Pretend they're charms and rate them that way. 5264. That said though in today's era of EDH, it's better to run cheaper, instant, but more niche removals like Ramp and removal are also a key piece for any EDH deck and now Planeswalkers get their own spicy tech! Gatewatch Beacon is a mana rock that can Graft Loyalty counters onto any entering Planeswalker (a must have for Step two: We turn the planeswalker artifact into a planeswalker artifact creature with Sydri or one of the following: [[Karn, Silver Golem]] [[Xenic Poltergeist]] [[Toymaker]] [[Karn's Touch]] Step three: We equip the planeswalker artifact creature with Helm of the Host. It seems like it would likely be very difficult to ult her. People are really bad at making fair magic cards. Custom Cards: Usually no. They need a certain something to support them in practice, and that thing is combat control, and boardwipes. Nuff said. 082%) Rank #15. Best route is to have compact/modal cards. But which spells are currently the best ones to run? This article lists the best white removal spells to play in EDH right now, Planeswalkers should be higher up because besides cards that specifically say "planeswalker", all damage spells that have "any target" can remove them, and combat removes damage them as well, also "nonland permanent" is one of Here is my latest take on the top 50 spot removal cards in Commander, in order of best to worst. Once it triggers it's ETB effect you have to have something like [[Stifle]] to counter it. 37 Chandra, hope's beacon 1. A two mana creature/planeswalker exile effect at instant speed is the holy grail of black’s removal qualities stapled onto one card. Oko, Thief of Crowns. Removal/Boardwipe: Duneblast, Supreme Verdict, The Elderspell, & Contagion Engine. Legendary Planeswalker - Minsc When ~ enters the battlefield and at the beginning of your upkeep, you may create Boo, a legendary 1/1 red Hamster creature token with trample and haste. A list of the most played MTG Commander Golgari Removal cards sorted by their popularity including their play trend. Cryptic Command, Snapcaster Mage, Creeping Tar Pit). Definetely will need some more creature removal. Planeswalkers 4K Gods 2K Devotion 2K Legends 1K Keeping planeswalkers alive in EDH can be hard. I love this one because if you’re in green or red it gives you the ability to turn a problem piece on the board into an artifact so [[Return To Nature]] or baby [[Vandalblast]] now become creature or planeswalker removal too. CMC: 3. Teferi (2) themes +1/+1 Counters (1) Auras (4) Blink (3) Bounce (5) Cantrips (1) Clones (2) Cycling (1) Discard (1) Enchantments (3 (Crazy Planeswalker Combos EDH) (EDH / Commander) in BlazerD945's Decks. Planeswalkers have somewhat lost their relevance and strength Much like the Wake, these are damaged-based removal effects that hit all planeswalkers and dorks. I've noticed a lot of magic players new to magic through edh. I’ve noticed people tend to just want to kill a planeswalker as soon as they see it. Teferi (2) themes +1/+1 Counters (1) Auras (4) Blink (3) Bounce (5) Cantrips (1) Clones (2) Cycling (1) Discard (1) Enchantments (3 Had a look at your list. 9 - 0 Commons. Planeswalker (7) Sorcery (9) (Click to view prices & decks) Abrupt Decay. Nicol Bolas, God-Pharaoh + Ajani Vengeant = if you could just remove your whole field off the table, that'd be great Teferi, Temporal Archmage + Oath of Teferi = activate planeswalkers twice on everyone's turns My current removal suite looks like this: Swords to plowshares Mortify Putrefy Anguished Unmaking Nature's claim I definitely do not want to cut anguished and swords, as those seem like very good removal spells. There are more direct ways to remove planeswalkers in modern Magic, but attacking is the primary way to get them off board. His -X is versatile enough to justify the cost. tldr; please share your favorite black removal - it can be spot removal or mass removal In EDh what are the best ways to protect Planewalkers. In my mind, budget spot removal (well, any spot removal really) typically fits into two categories: 1. This PLUS ability (which for sure should've been a minus) turns off combo pieces, commanders, equipment, mana dorks/rocks, and everything in between. Planeswalkers are strong cards with a lot of different abilities and combinations, so it's not easy to understand the strategy as an enemy. The Commander 2014 Planeswalker are all uMseful, especially Tefiri when he ults, but being able to protect your walkers is most important. Sorry! But they still have loads of value too! Instant and an X spell? Take out indestructible critters too? You can see the value here in both spells. Wrecking Ball planeswalkers as commanders tend to lead to longer games, because planeswalkers give you an extra decision each turn, because they enable staxx strategies, because they are an extra life total to attack, and because they don't attack themselves. If you play a PW to an open board it will get attacked and killed. IMO, planeswalkers are +1: Beast Within is an EDH all-star seeing play in almost every green deck, but this green deck doesn't quite have room for single use targeted removal. They're still good against Eldrazi, Ulamog particularly, but Also, which I have noticed some players don't know: your opponent can't instantly kill a Planeswalker with a removal spell when it hits the field. People say it would kill EDH as a format, and others say it will do nothing but give more options to an endless pool of commanders. Another player was desperate for some planeswalker removal, so he wanted to swing his commander, some big dragon, into the worst of the walkers. In 2021, we saw some very cool, but not overpowered 'walkers including some generically good 'walkers I actually really like, a planeswalker that does a lot of unique things, but I have no idea how to use them, and my favorite Rakdos card released in a long time. 35 - 0 Rares. Since its creature removal is damage based, and since [[bolt]] is basically the mana to damage cap (1 for 3) it makes sense for red to lag behind in a format filled with creatures that have 4+ toughness. Sort by. He might drive up the price of Planeswalkers&cards I'd say not to play: [[The chain veil]] win more, you'd rather play ramp, draw, control or another planeswalker instead of this. I think the weakest cards in the deck are; Inexorable Tide, Time Stop, Jace, Unraveler of Secrets. While gaining life via Contempt can be important if you've built Topdeck 3K Tokens 156 Control 102 Extra Turns 92 Planeswalkers 83. I think the -3 is paradoxically going to be a better way to get Dihada to her ult, because either the extra creatures or (more often) the mana will be important to defend her from attacks. The main reason why planeswalkers aren't quite as good in EDH as they are in other formats is because it's harder to protect them from four players as opposed to just Spot removal that can hit a planeswalker is somewhat limited but still widely played (ie. The suite of answers each deck needed would wider, the suite of “general” removal more narrow, and the end result is less deck-building diversity. I initially threw him in because ‘expensive planeswalker that I pulled from a pack’, but he has proven his value time and time again. Having to add planeswalker removal to the list of kinds of permanent removal you worry about would be really annoying. That's pretty much it. MTGO ARENA PAPER Commander meta Meta Planeswalker (2) Sorcery (8) (Click to view prices & decks) Decimate. After playing for a while, I remembered that allowing all Planeswalkers as commanders in EDHhas been a pretty controversial opinion, but is currently available in Brawl. I imagine I could have the board empty most the time being in mono black so creature based aggro towards her could be minimized but planeswalker removal is more common and permanent hate isn't extinct for sure. I don’t actually know your Teferi and Vivien are simply card type specific versions of [[Vedalken Orrery]] If you haven’t played against a combo deck or control deck with flash or a strong [[Yeva]] deck, I think you’ll continue to underestimate how strong flash is. Fateful Absence can be a valuable addition to a deck that frequently faces planeswalkers. You still get blue for counter magic, white for spot removal and board clears and green gives you ramp, but most importantly [[doubling season]] which causes your Planeswalkers to come into play with double the loyalty. > Introduction > Getting to Know the Deck Which planeswalkers printed recently have you found to be fairly effective in an EDH environment? Since War of the Spark we continue to see static abilities on walkers like [[teferi, master of time]] to get more activations or even [[lolth, spider Planeswalker deck with some combos. As much of a monster as it makes me sound: learning to play against permission/denial makes you The Elderspell | Illustration by Daarken. Call the Gatewatch: planeswalker tutor. Reaper King and other Scarecrows provides necessary removal options as well as blockers, which gives you time to tick up your planeswalkers. There are regular destroy cards like [[Murderous Rider]], temporary -X/-X effects like [[Tragic Slip]], and even exile removal like [[Overwhelming Remorse]]. Others that you want to keep around should only be played if you have the blockers and/or consistent access removal of threats to them. 209. Run LOTS of Chandra Nalaar - creature removal (also the planeswalker i have ulted the most with) Chandra, Pyromaster - pseudo draws Chandra, the Firebrand - "manaless" copy spell Daretti, Scrap Savant - fantastic draw regardless if artifact focused or not Koth of the Hammer - ramp Go to EDH r/EDH. And if they don't burn a Planeswalker removal is one of the less-run types. A free removal spell that exiles any creature. m. Good job. Destroying any creature or planeswalker at the cost of a single black mana and one measly creature is a crazy good effect; plenty of decks run Diabloic Edict Diabloic Edict and use the sacrifice as a bonus People say it would kill EDH as a format, and others say it will do nothing but give more options to a perpetually endless pool of commanders. Infernal grasp is obviously better, but it’s an insane rate for black removal that we haven’t seen before in a standard set. You have to protect your PWs by blockers, targeted removal and boardwipes. So you run into this situation of getting stuck with them in hand. Nor do I waste cards one them, often one swing from each player at a planeswalker means no planeswalker on your turn. Edit Live Edit. Most commander (as in your commander) removal is creature based and tuck friendly. That's the problem with red in edh. In 124755 decks 5% of Atraxa - Planeswalkers-Poison-Proliferate-Turns Commander / EDH GWUB Infect Proliferate Superfriends Turns. edh is likely the format where planeswalkers are the worst, but there is less planeswalker destruction outside of combat Two EDH archetypes got a boost -- Atraxa Superfriends and Sisay Toolbox. I’m just curious for tips on how to protect a planeswalker commander from boardwipes, removal, and combat damage. Planeswalkers are hard to interact with. Bombs When Proliferation is Present: Grimoire of the Dead: sure, I will happily take all of your creatures Meren of Clan Nel Toth. Well infernal grasp is a pretty new card. Very few creature heavy Naya decks would consider running cards so deep into burn like lightning bolt, fated conflagration, or lava spike. More often than not, they get removed through combat damage. I love any Planeswalker that fits into Bant because [[angus Mackenzie]] is a thing. Enchantments and enchantment removal are very much relevant in essentially every commander game alongside artifacts. The criteria I use to consider a card "removal" is that it targets (so no Wrath of The deck they are in and the plus effects are generally what determine a walkers effectiveness. Even boardwipes that hit planeswalkers and creatures, like [[hour of devastation]] so it's not a dead card against non-PW decks. People seem to be content on losing three life (it is a 40-life format, after all!) and spending on I'd say the relevant planeswalkers in EDH are ranked as follows: 1. I built a deck for him a while The removal package has always been something I've paid close attention to since my friends and I have dubbed the deck "Removal Tribal". EDIT: And as the previous reply said, direct damage et all, not just spells. This card mainly shines with its ultimate, I'm sorry to tell you but a PW deck probably won't be the best way to start EDH. Home MTG Commander Staples. At 6, it's fine, but not exceptional. There are many ways to get rid of a planeswalker including: removing loyalty Planeswalkers, creatures, enchantments, artifacts, nothing is safe when you’re up against a white deck. Anguished Unmaking Anguished Unmaking ranks as the most popular Orzhov removal spell, while Utter End Utter End is the fourth-most popular. Suggestions. Red is pretty good against planeswalkers, having access to burn. Lux Cannon: Destroy ANY permanent consistently? Yes. 2 mana removal is fine if it only removes 1 card type, but 3 Ramp and removal are also a key piece for any EDH deck and now Planeswalkers get their own spicy tech! Gatewatch Beacon is a mana rock that can Graft Loyalty counters onto any entering Planeswalker (a must have for any Superfriends deck), whilst Guff Rewrites History is a Chaos Warp supercharged, allowing each player to participate in the fun This is absurdly important in such a combo-dominated and boardwipe-heavy format as EDH. Rarity (main - side) 18 - 2 Mythic Rares. I bought the blue 2014 commander deck when it came out and have been slowly changing it to what it is now. In 72963 decks 7% of 1109954 decks. Play The necessity of casting it for its escape cost if you want it to remain on the battlefield can make it a hazard in EDH if you somewhat depend on There was a time when Dreadbore was possibly one of the best spot removal We were just exiting the Jace, the Mind Sculptor era. One of the players will be running a planeswalker deck with Atraxa as commander, I'm playing soldiers white weenie. Category. it also has a focus on countering or changing the target of my opponents spells. +1 turn a commander into an Elk and render whatever combos they have with that commander useless. Make sure you're doing your political work and pointing out when other players are going to win the game, that's about the only time you're going to get any breathing room. Just about every non-green red deck I'd made up to a certain point had at least 3 threaten effects. Reply reply creature/planeswalker removal (-3) creature/planeswalker reanimation (-4) Dramatic Scepter with a [[Gilded Lotus]] can pull this off (in which case your commander becomes the final combo piece Eat to Extinction Eat to Extinction is this rotation's version of Vraska's Contempt Vraska's Contempt, and I will say I'm always happy to see more options for planeswalker removal. BUT! I do warn people what this deck does prior to playing it. 0 0. I don't have any specifics besides the obvious like [[Swords to Plowshares]] and [[Vandalblast]], but my general rule when it comes to picking removal (not counting counter spells) is to 1. I think that the main reason why planeswalkers don't become EDH staples is the same reason why a planeswalker needs to check several [[Liliana, Dreadhorde General]] is one of the best planeswalkers in EDH, since she draws so many cards and her -4 can usually clear a board. If you're looking to dodge removal, I usually see a lot more artifact hate in EDH than planeswalker specific removal Reply reply Hikowa_Dean • Ahh ok, it's just that when people play planeswalkers, they always get wracked to death Even with your big planeswalker package, you forgot about the best planeswalker in the deck, [[Jace, Cunning castaway]] in combination with [[doubling season]] creates one of the most oppressive board states that are possible from this shell. by U p p e r D e c k e r T a c o. SHOW PRICES FOR . Deploy the Gatewatch: planeswalker Collected Company. 4c [[omnath, creation]] is my buddy's atraxa archenemy. 1. Although very old, clunky, and slow, Tsabo Tavoc still has a function: getting rid of enemy commanders in EDH. The reason these 'walkers are some of the most successful in Commander is the same reason a card like Thousand-Year Storm Thousand-Year Storm is good Planeswalker's can be great in EDH, just don't expect them to stick around very long. However, flexible burn spells do offer red a meaningful way to remove loyalty from planeswalkers. As Commander As Card Average Deck Decks. I convinced him to swing at the player instead and used my commander, [[Shu Yun]], in conjunction with a buff spell to make that one swing lethal. creature 25 artifact 9 enchantment 6 land 10 planeswalker 3 graveyards 2 hands 1. And even without it, planeswalkers can be attacked and easily ganged up on before they become a problem, compared to creatures who can sit for multiple turns on end if no one draws removal. the Gathering EDH/Commander! You have the monarch so you're drawing double the amount of cards, and I have a very non-budget 5 color Planeswalker deck and one of the cards that is amazing in the deck is Maelstrom Nexus and for me since the only creature in my deck is the general Ward of Bones is also amazing. And Angus can protect them really well. Darksteel Mutation is a popular card among EDH players that can be devastating if it successfully Planeswalkers can’t be interacted with in the same ways as creatures; in fact, many of the best ways to interact with a creature commander don’t work at all on a planeswalker. Below are our 10 best red removal spells in EDH. TheBestMagicCard. 75 Venser, the sojourner 1. Image View Timeline. Atraxa - Planeswalkers-Poison-Proliferate-Turns Commander / EDH GWUB Infect Proliferate Superfriends Turns. [[Jace, the Mind Sculptor]] has done some solid work in my [[Muzzio, Visionary Architect]] deck to help keep other players focused on recasting their commander from hand rather than trying to remove my artifacts. Upvote 0. Run the good gods in your colors, all the removal in the world since you're in arguably the best color Colorless is so starved for removal, that big Ugin basically is your only wrath (and mostly one-sided). In theory, Green is the color of big creatures, so you have access to some of the best creatures to attack Planeswalkers, along with fight spells and creatures with fight baked into them. PHILOSOPHY. I would suggest that you consider if the benefit of a single activation on your planeswalker is worth the cost of casting it, because 9 times out of 10, that's all you'll be Thanks to the increasing amount of planeswalker removal in White, Black, and Red, planeswalkers are far easier to kill than they have ever been. All of the I include 1 Planeswalker in every deck just as a feint. Wiping artifacts or enchantments is useful at every EDH pod I've ever played; wiping planeswalkers would be useful a handful of times. Sure, if you remove the worst 4 that are currently in there for the best 4 you are proposing, it would improve the deck - but swapping out Ajani for Tezzeret, Artifice Master or Narset, parter of Veils for Dovin Baan doesn't do a whole lot to improve the deck. 98 Teferi master of time 5. You can kill Lab Maniac with creature removal before they win. Was surprised to see Karn. [[Venser the sojourner]] blinking walkers is nice in theory, but they return in the end step when you can't use them anymore that turn. kinda don't get how important removal is, or being ready for incoming removal. Black removal refers to the mono-black cards that remove permanents from the battlefield. Or run tempo removal like bounce and unexpectedly absent, that won't solve the problem forever but can disrupt them at a critical time. MTGO ARENA PAPER Commander meta planeswalkers. A list of the most played MTG Commander Azorius Removal cards sorted by their popularity including their play trend. Planeswalkers have plenty of explicit payoffs with cards like The Chain Veil or Gatewatch Beacon, These days you can find him at the draft table, brewing his 20th EDH deck or cubing with friends on Arena. Here's my removal package: Targeted Removal. But unlike the Wake, they hurt you too. Creatures [[Karlov of the Ghost Council]] [[Vona, Butcher of Magan]] [[Solitude]] [[Vampire Hexmage]] (Descend Planeswalker Removal) Instants Removal is often defined as cards that can get permanents off the board. Upvoted 0. Because edh is so inherently casual you can do both, as opposed to a format like modern where if you don’t play to win In EDH, many decks lack early forms of interaction, and a lot of removal can not actually hit planeswalkers. You have a very high count of 19 planeswalkers, for not actually being able to protect them consistently. Running an [[Ayara, First of Locthwain]] deck and notice I need more removal! I'm new to EDH overall and there are SO MANY cards out there I don't even know exist and I always love to hear the communities thoughts. Removal is often defined as cards that can get permanents off the board. The Breya has now established his board and the Atraxa has zilch. You always get to activate your planeswalker's ability before they get priority, unless you do something that gives them priority like cast a spell or change phases which. Is there an effective way of removing planeswalkers I can use in the deck (should full-out aggro fail)? This is my current and main EDH deck. +1: Put three +1/+1 counters on up to one target creature with trample or haste. 00. Expensive but In this article, we'll show you an upgraded list for the Commander Masters precon, Planeswalker Party, besides explaining the list's strategy and which cards could be swapped for others. Esika, God of the Tree (Commander) - Planeswalkers . The truth is that you should only need one or two ultimate planeswalkers to win a game. Whoops. This article lists out the best spot removal cards, check this article if you are looking for the best board wipes in And Breya can use the thopters as removal if there's something unblockable, or inconvenient like an Atraxa. Who needs player removal if you have planeswalker Ive never lost a game of EDH because of a planeswalker and Ive never won in in EDH because of one either. One planeswalker, regardless of how strong it's preceived to be, is fairly easy to remove or keep under control in a pod of 4. But the fact that Anguished Unmaking isn't good enough astonishes me Swing into a planeswalker is basically free removal, the table usually can get into an agreement that they need to be targeted. Play trend: 2% The ability to recast the planeswalker over and over again is very powerful. Red excels at I think [[Athreos, Shroud-Veiled]] was made to be a mono-removal deck. Also, I ignored removal stapled to a creature (whether an ETB trigger or activated ability) as I will address those in the future as well. I don't really play higher powered EDH myself (75% optimized at maximum), so I don't really have a good grasp on what works and what doesn't there. It has some solid artifact hate but it struggles everywhere else. Reply Recently came across a decklist playing around 15-20 planeswalker and realized, I never thought about planeswalker tribal. Reply reply Mass removal for planeswalker would be Nice on white, You know, the color of mass removal From Krosan Grip to Blasphemous Act to good old Counterspell, removal is a key part of the typical EDH deck build. On the other hand, people tend not to pack planeswalker removal as much as creature removal because they are expecting to need to remove commanders. Planeswalkers don't transition well into commander frequently, which means that planeswalker removal tends to not be essential. Default Filters Card Filters. With this version of Kaya, your chances of that happening significantly The removal package has always been something I've paid close attention to since my friends and I have dubbed the deck "Removal Tribal". Creatures [[Karlov of the Ghost Build a super friends deck without green--its a way better and more fair/rewarding experience since doubling season is so strong with them. Surprise action against boardwipe heavy superfriends is very important. Planeswalker removal refers to any card that can remove a planeswalker from the battlefield for more than a turn (no blink effects, sorry). Planeswalkers evade a huge portion of that removal leaving the few answers left far short of handling a walker every time it pops out of the command zone. Everyone of your opponents knows that. Immortal sun just ends planeswalker abilities. Planeswalkers have somewhat lost their relevance and strength That leaves creature and planeswalker removal. Since then, I've regularly been playing it while we all wait out the pandemic. The best Planeswalkers in Commander are the ones that arent overly powerful at face value (i. Not sure if there is a thread on this already, but I was wanting to get people's opinions on which planeswalkers are best in a multiplayer format across all colors. I don't think the rules of commander should be changed to allow planeswalkers. Narset, Parter of Veils. If Karn or Daretti hit the table, the game becomes about finding a way to remove them. I don't mean the commanders that are specifically designed to be commanders, but having planeswalkers in general be commanders. In this day and age, every deck has plenty of legendary cards due to their sheer power, but repeatable commander removal is good, and this Phyrexian horror can also block legends like a champ. MtGDS. Patron of the Arts - Building Decks with Art Series Cards. Like 2 years ago, [[Hero’s Downfall]] was still decent black spot removal, and murderous rider came out and was basically hero’s downfall but came with a creature. Things like [[arena Rector]] + [[Neoform]] allow you to search for any Planeswalker you want, drop it down, and then throw down a [[deepglow skate]]. Strong colors with extremely strong cards to remove, draw or ramp. And with all the artifact/enchantment removal running around, planeswalkers are much harder to remove. the pulse is good, and her -7 is a wincon With the first two, you can name the planeswalker, and now its a pretty face with nothing to do but sit there. 25 Teferi, temporal archmage 1. Add to folder Copy. If it's a dedicated Planeswalker deck with the appropriate protection, a piece of hate isn't going to do much, you'll need the other answers anyway. knx vohja askktt cpr srmrsn zggsquh aasgs xoqw bjg qgjzi